Why do we keep driving even when we want not to?
2026-11-17Many people want to travel more sustainably, but good intentions rarely translate into action. Henrik Johansson Rehn has examined the theory that major life events can open a “window of opportunity” for positive behavioural change. His findings suggest that whether people actually leave the car at home is often determined by factors that are far more mundane.
Henrik Johansson Rehn, who recently earned a PhD in psychology and conducted his research at the Service Research Center (CTF), explored a long-standing idea in behavioural research in his dissertation, In Search of the “Window of Opportunity” for Car Use Reduction: The Role of Life Events. The theory suggests that people are generally better psychologically equipped to adopt more sustainable travel habits when they experience major life events, such as moving home or changing jobs.
– Because these types of events often involve changes to everyday routines, they increase the likelihood that previously habitual behaviours become more conscious and subject to reflection, explains Henrik Johansson Rehn.
– The idea has been that if people are motivated to, for example, cycle to work instead of driving, it should be easier for them to make that change when their old habits are no longer acting as barriers. This is why life events have been described as a ‘window of opportunity’ for positive behavioural change.
However, the findings of Johansson Rehn’s dissertation complicate this picture. At the group level, the researchers found no evidence that people who had experienced major life events were more reflective in their decision-making or more motivated to reduce their car use. Instead, these factors were associated with having changed one’s travel behaviour, regardless of whether the change was triggered by a life event.
– In our follow-up study at the individual level, only a small proportion of those who reported reduced car use could be explained by the psychological theories that underpin the idea of a ‘window of opportunity’, says Johansson Rehn.
Overall, the findings suggest that life events themselves do not produce the psychological effects often assumed in previous research. Whether life events facilitate sustainable transitions appears to depend primarily on individual circumstances and practical conditions.
Can moving house be the perfect opportunity to break car dependence?
– It can be, but it does not have to be,” says Henrik Johansson Rehn. “One of the key points in my dissertation is that a life event in itself does not necessarily create more favourable psychological conditions for reducing car use. However, for those who can choose where to live, that choice often has a major impact on travel behaviour.
A move can affect access to public transport, cycling infrastructure, and walkable environments, thereby shaping travel patterns and car use for many years. Previous research has shown that people differ significantly in the importance they place on everyday mobility when choosing where to live.
So why do we keep driving even when we want to travel more sustainably?
– There is no single answer to that question,” says Henrik Johansson Rehn. “But based on my dissertation, we can conclude that intention alone is not enough.”
One of the studies measured people’s intentions to reduce car use and found that even very strong and persistent intentions needed to be accompanied by other factors in order to explain reduced car use one year later.
– In addition to practical opportunities, it is important to be sufficiently reflective in how decisions about everyday travel are made,” says Johansson Rehn. “This is probably a psychological prerequisite for acting on one’s intentions and breaking established behavioural patterns.
At the same time, the study showed that many people who reduced their car use had previously lacked both strong intentions and the psychological characteristics normally associated with behaviour change.
– My interpretation is that reduced car use often occurs as a result of changing practical circumstances, and that people’s intentions, in the traditional sense, may not be as important as we tend to think.
What does it really take for people to leave the car at home more often?
– At a broader societal level, the rule of thumb is simple and fairly obvious: driving needs to become less advantageous compared to other options, says Henrik Johansson Rehn. At the same time, many people already want to reduce their car use, and have the opportunity to do so, but struggle to make it happen.
His advice is straightforward: be more specific.
– It is easy to fall into the trap of ‘all or nothing’ thinking, which can prevent people from doing anything at all or trying something new. Start turning intentions into actions by identifying which car journeys you can replace and how. Perhaps the shortest trip you usually drive is the easiest place to begin.
He also recommends making practical preparations in advance, such as checking bus timetables or making sure bicycle tyres are properly inflated. Another effective strategy is to establish clear personal rules that reduce the need for spontaneous decision-making.
– Leaving decisions open until the moment often means we end up doing what we usually do. For example, you might tell yourself, and perhaps others, ‘On Tuesday I’m taking the bus to work, which means I need to leave home at 7:15,’ or ‘On Thursday I’ll cycle unless it’s raining or snowing.’