Multiple pathways to successful supplier relationships
2026-11-18When a supplier misses a critical delivery, how should the buyer respond? By demanding more frequent reporting, clarifying performance requirements, or investing in the relationship itself? A study of 55 Swedish companies’ international supplier relationships provides insights that can help guide such decisions.
Janet Rasaei and Alexandre Sukhov examined how management control, trust, cultural understanding, and expectations of continued collaboration interact in outsourcing relationships with independent overseas suppliers.
– We identified two patterns associated with perceived success, says Alexandre Sukhov, Associate Professor of Business Administration at Karlstad Business School and researcher at the Service Research Center (CTF), Karlstad University. In the first, outcome control was combined with shared norms, supplier autonomy, trust, cultural understanding, and a long-term orientation. The second was characterized by shared norms, trust, and expectations of continued collaboration, with a low degree of formal control. However, this does not mean that contracts are unimportant.
What can purchasing managers and strategic decision-makers learn?
– A key lesson is to examine whether monitoring and control mechanisms fit the conditions of the relationship, says Janet Rasaei, PhD in Business Administration and Postdoctoral Researcher at the Department of Economics, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences (SLU). The study suggests that management control should be viewed as a package, where several elements need to be understood together.
In cases of recurring delivery problems, the model can for example be used to structure discussions before a supplier meeting:
- Do both parties agree on the outcomes that should be achieved?
- Are there shared norms regarding responsibility and problem-solving?
- Is there trust in the supplier’s competence and intentions?
- Do both parties expect the relationship to continue in the future?
This represents one possible practical application of the model rather than interventions whose effects were directly tested in the study.
Bridging accounting and industrial organization
The study’s main theoretical contribution is a more precise understanding of how different control mechanisms are combined with specific relational conditions. In doing so, it connects research on management control and accounting with questions of strategic sourcing and the organization of supplier relationships.
The findings are also relevant to the new academic field of Industrial Organization and Innovation at Karlstad University within Industrial Engineering and Management. The study may serve as a starting point for interdisciplinary collaboration, for example on how control and trust interact when suppliers take on greater strategic responsibility. It also demonstrates how the Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA) method can be used to investigate such complex questions.
The results are based on a survey in which participants assessed their supplier relationships at a specific point in time. The study identifies associations between management practices and perceived success, but it does not establish direct causal relationships.