History HR Excellence in Research

In September 2019, an application was submitted and assessed by external experts. In March 2020, our application received partial approvement, with a request for supplementary information. 

Karlstad University received the HR Excellence in Research Award in September 2020. The implementation of the Charter and Code and the measures and activities detailed in the action plan for Karlstad University, is ongoing. In the autumn of 2022, a new revision of the action plan was made. The European Commission conducted a new assessment to make sure that we  fulfilled our commitments. Focus groups, workshops and surveys was conducted during the spring of 2022, where we identified further activities for the revised action plan. In May 2022, a revised Action Plan was adopted with 8 new activities and revised timetables for some of the activities from the previous Action Plan that had not yet been implemented.

In August 2022 the revised Action plan together with an self-assessment was submitted to the European Commission for assessment. We got the results back in December 2022, short summary is below.

The European Commission assessed how well we managed to implement our current action plan, how well we have spread the HRS4R and the principles in the organisation and the work with the HRS4R in general, including the work of the implementation group. They were very satisfied with Kau's work and we have received the best possible rating in this first evaluation.

The rating scale from the EU is set at 3 levels in the interim assessment;

1.  
   1. HRS4R embedded - Karlstad University received this rating, the highest possible.
   2. HRS4R embedded, corrective actions needed
   3. HRS4R embedded, strong corrective actions needed

The Commission encourages Karlstad University to continue as we have done until the next review and is also satisfied with the actions we have decided for the revised action plan. Furthermore, it calls for increased communication to the organization.

Below are some extracts from the EC Consensus Report - the Commission's report:

Strengths

Karlstad University has undertaken a deep exercise about detecting strong and weak points for analysis. HR issues have been worked in a very professional way.

Good practices have been found such as "Karlstad University has established an Open science and data working group" or strong involvement and consultation of researchers and admin. staff, or the great webpage about new staff.

The HR webpage is very complete

Weaknesses

Good actions (i.e. professional development information) seem not to reach all the scientific community. Some communication efforts should be devoted.

Some comments on extended/changed indicators in the action plan, also that a document aimed at managers was not in English, which we will remedy.

In 2022, the latest version of the action plan was developed in collaboration with researchers at all levels, university management and support functions. It includes the following:

• Examining career support at the University, where we are today, how we compare internationally and where we want to be
• Implementing activities from the co-authorship report
• Investigate and develop the conditions for collaboration with the wider community
• Develop digital recruitment course available to all those working in recruitment
• Implement the EU Open Science Policy

Examples of areas that have undergone development in recent years include:

• Peer supervision
• Continuing professional development of doctoral supervisors
• Career guidance during staff appraisals
• Information programmes regarding career opportunities outside of academia
• Rules concerning co-authorship
• Policy documents concerning the work performed by doctoral students 

The HR Excellence in Research process at Karlstad University 

The aim of The Charter and Code is to create the world’s most competitive knowledge-based economy, with the help of European research activities.By improving the conditions for free research, promoting an open labour market for researchers and enabling recruitment and retainment of outstanding researchers, a strong European research area can be established. Through this, an attractive and sustainable labour market for researchers can be achieved. The aim of the Charter and Code is also to ensure that the relationship between researchers and employer contribute to successful research, as well as access to and exchange of knowledge, technological advancements and career development.

All employees at Karlstad University were invited to participate in workshops or to contribute with their thoughts in other ways.
A GAP analysis and an action plan with scheduled activities were developed based on workshops with researchers representing all levels and faculties, as well as university management.

The Charter and Code comprises 40 principles, divided up into four areas:

• Ethical and Professional aspects
• Recruitment and Selection
• Working conditions
• Training and professional development

These principles are used as policy document at Karlstad University, so policies, procedures and regulations have been updated to correspond to the principles.

Contents of the Charter and Code

The Charter and Code comprises general principles and requirements that determine roles, responsibilities and rights for researchers and employers. These principles serves as a framework, guiding the work performed by researchers and employers.

Consequently, employers who adopt and implement the Charter and Code demonstrate their commitment to act responsibly and professionally towards their employees. Employers commit to promoting equal treatment and transparent recruitment, as well as offering fair conditions for researchers and contributing to the development of the European research area. The aim is to become an attractive work place for researchers seeking employment or a host for their research projects.